I recently post on lain Abernethy’s forum about one of the issues of using large blocking movements. In this article I am going to expand on the ideas presented in that post.
People who study bunkai and application to the forms movements are usually in agreement that many of the movements labeled as ‘blocks’ are in fact something else. The reasoning behind this is very sound. As an example ‘San Makgi’, for this movement to be a used as a block we have to have a very specific situation and also be confident enough to block 2 attacks at the same time.
Clearly, when we take some movements as blocks we run into a few problems. However, there is one more problem that is worth discussing. That is one of natural movement and mindset. When we are protecting ourselves or in a state of panic and fear, we tend to make ourselves small and be in a tight position. Our hands come up tight round our head to protect ourselves from whatever is coming towards us.
Even if we are prepared for an attack this can happen. If we look at MMA competitors or boxers, who are in a highly conditioned and in a high state of readiness, they will still resort to bringing the hands up in a protective posture rather than blocking each individual attack. This is a natural defensive movement and as such is very difficult to override. Especially when we are not prepared for an attack.
Now if we take this into consideration and then look at the blocking movement in many of the patterns, we can see that the exact opposite is happening. We are extending our arms and infacting offering ourselves less protection than the more natural position that our body wants to adopt when under threat. We can see this clearly in the openg positions of many of the patterns, Do San or Joong Gun for example would have us in fairly open postures in response to an incoming attack.
Now you can make the argument that the movements in the patterns represent ideas and the ‘openness’ of the movements is there just for demonstration purposes. However, I don’t feel this has much validity as the amount we have to change the movements to make them practical would render the original movements useless.
I have stated before, but it is worth repeating that I feel in many cases the cross hands ‘chamber position’ is a much better defence. It is closer to our natural flinch response and puts us in a better position to grab limbs and execute counter attacks.
I have written before how that can be seen in Do San, but we can also see it in Yul Gok with the middle forearm block and even the low block in Chon Ji can be better applied in this way.
Are there times when an extended block may work? Yes, of course there are, but as well as the movement we have to consider the mindset required for that movement to be effective. To be that open and to move forward into an attack we have to be aggressive and have some degree of confidence.
This of course goes for other movements as well. Whenever we train we need to consider the not just the technical and physical aspects for a technique but also the mindset required to make the technique work. Mindset itself is something that we need to spend time working on but that is for another article.